null
Excluding Doublets in FACS Analysis: A Comprehensive Guide

Excluding Doublets in FACS Analysis: A Comprehensive Guide

Overview: Doublet discrimination is essential in Fluorescence-Activated Cell Sorting (FACS) to ensure accurate results, as doublets (two cells sticking together) can resemble single cells or falsely increase fluorescence signals. By following a systematic approach to exclude doublets, you can improve the accuracy and reliability of your data. This guide covers the steps for identifying and excluding doublets based on signal characteristics, with a focus on forward scatter (FSC), side scatter (SSC), and fluorescence parameters.


1. Importance of Doublet Exclusion in FACS


Doublets, often appearing as clusters or aggregates, can lead to:


  • Misleading results in fluorescence intensitymeasurements
  • Distorted cell cycle analysis due to combined DNA content
  • Inaccurate cell population gating

Excluding doublets is particularly critical in experiments where precise cell quantification is essential, such as cell cycle studies, apoptosis assays, and multicolor immunophenotyping.


2. Key FACS Parameters for Doublet Exclusion


2.1 Forward Scatter and Side Scatter Basics


  • FSC (Forward Scatter):Measures cell size by detecting scattered light in the forward direction.
  • SSC (Side Scatter): Measures cell granularity or internal complexity based on side-scattered
    light.

While FSC and SSC alone may not always distinguish doublets, they are essential for primary cell gating.


2.2 Understanding Area (A), Height (H), and Width (W) Parameters


  • Area (A): Represents the total integrated signal under the pulse and is directly proportional to cell size.
  • Height (H): Measures the peak of the signal pulse; a doublet may have a higher peak than a single cell.
  • Width (W): Reflects the pulse duration as the cell passes through the laser beam. Doublets tend to produce wider pulses than single cells.

3. Step-by-Step Doublet Discrimination


3.1 Primary Gating with Forward Scatter Parameters (FSC-A vs. FSC-H)


 Plot FSC-A vs. FSC-H for Doublet Identification


  • Rationale Doublets generate a higher peak height relative to area compared to single cells.
  • Procedure: Plot FSC-A (area) on the x-axis and FSC-H (height) on the y-axis.
  • Expected Pattern: Single cells form a tight, linear population along a diagonal, as area and height correlate directly for single cells. Doublets and larger aggregates deviate from this line.
  • Gating Strategy: Gate around the linear population to retain single cells and exclude
    events above or below this line.

Parameter
Description
Purpose
FSC-A
Integrated area under the pulse
Represents total cell size
FSC-H
Peak height of the pulse
Shows peak signal intensity
Single Cell
Diagonal linear pattern in FSC-A vs FSC-H
Allows easy single-cell identification

3.2 Secondary Gating with Forward Scatter Width (FSC-W vs. FSC-H)


Plot FSC-W vs. FSC-H for Enhanced Doublet Discrimination


  • Rationale: Doublets produce wider pulses due to the combined width of two cells passing together.
  • Procedure: Plot FSC-W (width) on the x-axis and FSC-H (height) on the y-axis.
  • Expected Pattern: Single cells will have a narrow width and a tight cluster, while doublets will appear as a distinct population with higher width.
  • Gating Strategy: Exclude events with higher FSC-W, which are likely doublets, by gating around the single-cell population.

Parameter
Description
Purpose
FSC-W
Width or duration of the pulse
Differentiates narrow single cells
Doublets
Wider pulse due to multiple cells
Distinguishable as a separate group

3.3 Side Scatter (SSC) Parameters for Additional Gating (SSC-A vs. SSC-H or SSC-W)


  • Rationale: SSC can also help exclude doublets, particularly in heterogeneous samples.
  • Procedure: Plot SSC-A vs. SSC-H or SSC-W vs. SSC-H to examine signal characteristics in side scatter. 
  • Expected Pattern: Like FSC, single cells will form a tight population, while doublets will exhibit a broader SSC-W or deviate from the SSC-A vs. SSC-H linearity.
  • Gating Strategy: Use SSC parameters if additional discrimination is needed, particularly in
    samples with granularity differences among cell types.

4. Fluorescence-Based Doublet Discrimination


For samples with fluorescent markers, fluorescence parameters can provide additional doublet discrimination.


4.1 Fluorescence Area vs. Height (Fl-A vs. Fl-H) Plotting


  • Rationale: Doublets display higher fluorescence due to two cells with combined fluorescence signals, which can increase both area and height disproportionately.
  • Procedure: Plot Fluorescence Area (Fl-A) vs. Fluorescence Height (Fl-H) for each fluorescent channel.
  • Expected Pattern: Single cells form a diagonal pattern where area and height correlate linearly. Doublets and aggregates deviate from this line due to increased fluorescence.
  • Gating Strategy: Gate along the linear population to exclude fluorescence events with disproportionate height or area, indicative of doublets.

4.2 Practical Example of Gating Sequence


Step
Parameter(s)
Axis
Description
Primary Gating
FSC-A vs. FSC-H
x, y
Gate linear population to exclude major doublets
Secondary Gating
FSC-W vs. FSC-H
x, y
Exclude events with broad width to further refine singles
Fluorescence Check
Fl-A vs. Fl-H (optional)
x, y
Use if fluorescence signals require further refinement

5. Sequential Gating Strategy for Doublet Exclusion


  1. Gate FSC-A vs. FSC-H: Retain events along the linear line to exclude primary doublets.
  2. Gate FSC-W vs. FSC-H: Exclude events with higher FSC-W, which are likely doublets or larger
    aggregates.
  3. Apply SSC Parameters (if needed): For more complex samples, use SSC-A vs. SSC-H or SSC-W vs. SSC-H to refine doublet exclusion further.
  4. Use Fluorescence Gating (Fl-A vs. Fl-H): For fluorescently labeled cells, add a fluorescence-based check to ensure high-fluorescence doublets are excluded.

6. Tips and Validation



  • Run control samples: Use a sample of known single cells to validate your gating strategy.
  • Optimize gating for cell type: Different cell types or experimental conditions may require adjustments in gating parameters.
  • Verify with multiple parameters: Using combinations of FSC, SSC, and fluorescence plots enhances accuracy in doublet exclusion.

By following a systematic approach to doublet exclusion, you can ensure more accurate FACS data analysis, leading to reliable and interpretable results across various applications.

5th Nov 2024 Zainab Riaz

Recent Posts